Fox News, Drudge, Malkin Accused Obama of Making Up 2006 Hawaiian Earthquake

Here Is Fox News’ Oct. 2006 Report on the Big Island’s 6.6 Quake

screenshot-fox-coverage-of-hawaii-quake

The latest false rumor floated on the right is that, during his interview with Fox News’ right-wing shill Bret Baier this week, Pes. Obama falsely stated that an earthquake hit Hawaii in 2006:

PRES. OBAMA: It was said that there were billions — millions of dollars going to Louisiana, this was a special deal. Well, in fact, that provision, which I think should remain in, said that if a state has been affected by a natural catastrophe, that has created a special health care emergency in that state, they should get help. Louisiana, obviously, went through Katrina, and they’re still trying to deal with the enormous challenges that were faced because of that.

(CROSS TALK)

OBAMA: That also — I’m giving you an example of one that I consider important. It also affects Hawaii, which went through an earthquake. So that’s not just a Louisiana provision. That is a provision that affects every state that is going through a natural catastrophe. [Emphasis added.]

Media Matters traced the genesis of the lie:

Right-wing blogs: “What earthquake in Hawaii?”

Jim Hoft: “Um… What earthquake in Hawaii?” At 6:54 p.m. on March 17, right-wing blogger Jim Hoft wrote a Gateway Pundit post that stated, “Either Obama’s completely making up stuff now or we all missed some horrible devastating earthquake in Hawaii.” He later wrote: “In 1868 there was a major earthquake in Hawaii that killed 77 people. In 1975 an earthquake in Hawaii killed 2 people.”

Breitbart.tv links to Hoft. At 10:18 p.m. on March 17, Andrew Breitbart’s website Breitbart.tv linked to Hoft’s post and displayed the headline, “Puzzling statement: Obama says ‘Louisiana Purchase’ will help with the earthquake in Hawaii.”

Drudge links to Breitbart.tv post. From the Drudge Report: “Puzzling Statement: Obama Says ‘Louisiana Purchase’ Will Help With the Earthquake in Hawaii’…

Hot Air picks up the false story, as does Michelle Malkin, etc.

Finally it winds up on Fox News’ amateur-hour morning show, “Fox and Friends”:

[Steve] Doocy follows talking points from right-wing blogs. During the March 18 edition of Fox & Friends, co-host Steve Doocy played the quote in question from Obama’s interview and responded: “Hold it. What Hawaiian earthquake? There was an earthquake in 1868 that killed 77. There was an earthquake in 1975 that killed two.”

It’s unclear whether these people didn’t bother to check the Google, or whether they did a search and then knowingly lied. Fox News’ coverage of the quake was easy to find. A search on “foxnews.com earthquake Hawaii 2006″ brought up this story from the Fox News website in about two seconds.

Here’s the complete text of the story — and we have preserved screenshots of the article in situ on the Fox News website in case, you know, Fox might lose it or make it disappear:

Powerful 6.6-Magnitude Earthquake, Aftershocks Rattle Hawaii

HONOLULU — A strong earthquake shook Hawaii early Sunday, jolting residents out of bed and causing a landslide that blocked a major highway. Ceilings crashed at a hospital, and aftershocks kept the state on edge.

The state Civil Defense had unconfirmed reports of injuries, but communication problems prevented more definite reports. Gov. Linda Lingle issued a disaster declaration for the entire state, saying there had been damage to buildings and roads. There were no reports of fatalities.

The quake hit at 7:07 a.m. local time, 10 miles north-northwest of Kailua Kona, a town on the west coast of Hawaii Island, also known as the Big Island, said Don Blakeman, a geophysicist at the National Earthquake Information Center, part of the U.S. Geological Survey.

• Monitor the situation in FOXNews.com’s Natural Disasters Center.

Blakeman said there was no risk of a Pacific-wide tsunami, but there was a possibility of significant wave activity in Hawaii.

The Pacific Tsunami Center reported a preliminary magnitude of 6.5, while the U.S. Geological Survey gave a preliminary magnitude of 6.6. The earthquake was followed by several strong aftershocks, including one measuring a magnitude of 5.8, the Geological Survey said.

“We were rocking and rolling,” said Anne LaVasseur, who was on the second floor of a two-story, wood-framed house on the east side of the Big Island when the temblor struck. “I was pretty scared. We were swaying back and forth, like King Kong’s pushing your house back and forth.”

Water pipes exploded at Aston Kona By The Sea, an 86-unit condominium resort, creating a dramatic waterfall down the front of the hotel from the fourth floor, said Kenneth Piper, who runs the front desk.

“We are a concrete building, but we really shook. You could almost see the cars bouncing up and down in the parking garage,” he said.

The quake caused widespread power outages, and phone communication was possible, but difficult. By midday Sunday, power was restored to Hilo on the Big Island and was starting to be restored to Maui, said Chuck Anthony, a spokesman for the Hawaii National Guard. Officials did not have a firm estimate of how many people were without power.

Lingle told radio station KSSK that she toured the Kona area by helicopter to view the damage, including earth falling into Kealakekua Bay.

“You could see the water was turning brown,” said Lingle.

A FEMA computer simulation of the quake estimated that as many as 170 bridges on the Big Island could have suffered damage in the temblor, said Bob Fenton, FEMA director of response for the region. More than 50 federal officials were en route to the Big Island to assess damage and begin recovery work, he said.

On Hawaii Island, there was some damage in Kailua-Kona and a landslide along a major highway, said Gerard Fryer, a geophysicist at the Pacific Tsunami Center. Officials also said there were reports of people trapped in elevators in Oahu.

In Waikiki, one of the state’s primary tourism areas, worried visitors began lining up outside convenience stores to purchase food, water and other supplies. Managers were letting tourists into the darkened stores one at a time.

Karie and Bryan Croes waited an hour to buy bottles of water, chips and bread. “It’s quite a honeymoon story,” said Karie as she and her husband sat in lounge chairs surrounded by their grocery bags beside a pool at ResortQuest Waikiki Beach Hotel.

Kona Community Hospital on the western side of Big Island was being evacuated after ceilings collapsed and power was cut off, according to a hospital spokeswoman.

At least 10 acute care patients were being evacuated across the island to a medical center in Hilo, said Terry Lewis, spokeswoman for the hospital. About 30 nursing care patients were being moved temporarily to a nearby conference center, she said.

“We were very lucky that no one got hurt,” said Lewis.

Power was back up in the hospital, and its emergency room was accepting patients, hospital officials said. One operating room that sustained minimal damage was available for use if necessary.

The quake affected travel plans for many visitors, though the state was in its low period of the tourism season. Airports were functioning despite the power outages, though travel was difficult and some flights were being canceled, officials said.

Federal Aviation Administration spokesman Les Dorr said planes were arriving at Honolulu International Airport, but there were few departures. Dorr said the Transportation Security Administration security checkpoints were without power, so screeners were screening passengers and baggage manually.

Resorts in Kona were being asked to keep people close to hotels, Big Island Mayor Harry Kim told television station KITV. Cruise ships were asked to keep tourists on board, and ships that were due to dock with tourists were asked to move on to their next location, he said.

“We are dealing with a lot of scared people,” he said.

Hotels throughout the islands reported scattered injuries and disruptions. Many hotel managers broadcast warnings over public-address systems that echoed through corridors.

Earthquakes in the 6.0 magnitude range are rare in the region, though they have happened before. The region more commonly sees temblors in the 3- and 4-magnitude range caused by volcanic activity.

“We think this is a buildup from many volcanic earthquakes that they’ve had on the island,” Waverly Person, a geophysicist with the U.S. Geological Survey’s National Earthquake Information Center.

The last Hawaiian earthquake this strong struck more than 20 years ago. The magnitude 6.7 caused heavy property damage on Hawaii Island and collapsed trails into a volcano in Hawaiian Volcanoes National Park on Nov. 16, 1983. A 6.1-magnitude quake also hit in 1989, according to the Earthquake Information Center.

The largest recorded Hawaiian earthquake struck the Ka’u District on Hawaii Island in 1868, causing 77 deaths. Its magnitude was estimated at 7.9.

A 9.5-magnitude earthquake, the largest in the world, struck Chile on May 22, 1960, and a tsunami traveled to Hawaii where 61 people died.

10 Comments

  • Nikolai
    March 19, 2010 - 12:58 pm | Permalink

    Pretty funny..

    I thought the same thing (What earthquake?) at first, but figured Obama knew what he was talking about (he did) being from Hawaii.

    The teabaggers and/or righties and other assorted kooks champed at the bit to blog about what-the-hell-is-Obama-talking-about? etc.

    Now, see the difference between rational thought processes and irrational thought processes teabaggers and/or righties and the rest of you kooks?

    No? Didn’t think so…

  • March 19, 2010 - 1:05 pm | Permalink

    Why let the facts get in the way of yet another Swiftboat smear?

    FAUX Gnus is without a doubt a criminal organization. We have the constitutional right to free speech. However, free speech does not include a consistent long term pattern of lying, slander and libel.

    In fact, one could argue that the pattern of lies, slander and libel is actually treason, since their objective is to interfere with the voting process as well as to bring down a legitimately elected U.S. Government.

  • jon
    March 19, 2010 - 1:34 pm | Permalink

    @ Kevin Schmidtty –

    Actually Foxnews just won a case that allowed to them “manipulate” the news as “lying” is not illegal.

    pretty fuckin retarded if you ask me.

  • @meryl333
    March 19, 2010 - 1:38 pm | Permalink

    Someone tweeted this story link and I thought it must be a joke. Seems like everything coming out of the corporate owned propaganda creation stream is so outrageous I can’t believe it’s serious. But they are… and it is.

  • March 19, 2010 - 3:05 pm | Permalink

    Unfortunately, you can’t fix stupid. FOX News and the dittoheads to the Right bask in their ignorance, while completely ignoring facts. Just watch how pretty much all of them work…

    First, a questionable story breaks. The Right plasters it all over the net, radio, and TV without fact checking it. They exhaust the story until others find it to be false. At this point, they just drop the story without anymore mention. They do not backtrack on their words, but rather let the rumors radiate. Welcome to the Right Wing propaganda machine user manual!

  • Emilio
    March 19, 2010 - 5:31 pm | Permalink

    The adults are on extended vacation and have left the lords and ladies of the flies in charge, but they’ve taken leave of their senses. These right-wing-nut-jobs are so bitter about a black man being president they can’t even see straight, let alone think logically.

  • Merilyn Hand
    March 21, 2010 - 10:29 pm | Permalink

    why don’t you ask the people of Hawaii? We were there and yes, it did happen and yes, it was substantial.

  • Merilyn Hand
    March 21, 2010 - 10:30 pm | Permalink

    It happened, I was in it! This whole thing is psychotic.

  • mossydog
    March 22, 2010 - 9:31 am | Permalink

    On the other hand here is something of much greater significance and not talked about by these people at all.http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/03/19/hannitys-freedom-concerts_n_505294.html

  • Emilio
    March 22, 2010 - 10:55 am | Permalink

    Froth and frothing at the mouth loons. These numskulls believe that we all have the same shallow brains they have been endowed with. They remind me of a pack of wild beasts, mindlessly following their insane leader in pursuit of a phantom prey. Why should these ridiculous morons have any say in the political life of this nation?

  • Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>